Unusual Solitaire Engagement Rings: A Guide to Unique Single Stone Designs

Choosing an engagement ring is a significant and exciting journey, especially when you're looking for something that stands out from the crowd. In this guide, we'll explore some great options for those looking at unusual solitaire engagement rings, from unique stone shapes and distinctive settings to customisation options and real-life case studies. Let's create a one-of-a-kind ring that truly reflects your love story.

Bridal Solitaire set

What is a Solitaire Ring?

A solitaire ring is a classic design featuring a single stone as the focal point. It's a timeless choice for engagement rings for women and men, known for its elegance and simplicity. The solitaire engagement ring highlights the beauty of the chosen stone, making it a perfect canvas for showcasing unique and alternative designs.

Introduction to Unusual Solitaire Engagement Rings

Unusual solitaire engagement rings offer a twist on the traditional, bringing unique and distinctive designs to the forefront. Whether you prefer a quirky engagement ring or a more simple design, creating a bespoke piece ensures your ring is as unique as your relationship

Step Cut Diamond Engagement Rings 

Step cut diamonds, like emerald or Asscher cuts, offer a sophisticated look with their clean lines and reflective facets. These stones are perfect for those who appreciate a sleek and elegant design. More unusual step cut diamond shapes are becoming increasingly popular with stunning designs such as this oval step cut diamond engagement ring.

Coloured Diamond Engagement Rings

Coloured diamonds add a vibrant touch to your engagement ring. Whether you choose a yellow, blue, or pink diamond, the pop of colour makes your ring truly unique. Earthy toned diamond like a brown or cognac diamond are perfect when paired with yellow gold or rose gold for a rich look. This brown oval diamond solitaire is a perfect example.

Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Rings 

Rose cut diamonds, with their flat bottoms and dome-shaped tops, create a vintage feel. They reflect light beautifully and offer a distinctive alternative to modern cuts. Rose cut diamonds also appear deceptively large for their carat weight in comparison to other diamond shapes, this is because they are cut without as much depth as the usual diamond shapes. So not only do they look larger than you would expect (which is always a bonus when it comes to diamonds!), but you can also have an engagement ring which is set low to the finger which is extremely practical for everyday wear. This Rose Cut Diamond Solitaire not only looks much larger than it’s equivalent round diamond, but looks stunning in its simplistic setting.

Alternative Gemstones (Sapphires, Emeralds, Tanzanite) 

Opting for coloured gemstone engagement rings, such as sapphires, emeralds, or tanzanite, can add a splash of personality to your ring. These stones are not only stunning but also steeped in rich history and symbolism.

Bezel Settings 

Bezel set engagement rings feature a metal rim that encircles the stone, offering a modern and secure option. This setting is ideal for those with an active lifestyle as the stone is held very securely, or for those who prefer a sleek, contemporary design. 

Claw Settings 

Claw set engagement rings, also known as prong settings, hold the stone with several metal claws. This classic setting allows maximum light to enter the stone, enhancing its brilliance and sparkle. Claw set rings come in many variations from the classic four or six claw styles, to more intricate 8 and 10 claw designs or a modern three claw ring.

Vintage-Inspired Settings 

For lovers of old-world charm, vintage-inspired settings bring a touch of the past into your present. Think intricate details, millgrain edges, and art deco engagement rings that echo the elegance of bygone eras with their angular designs and engraved details.

Modern and Artistic Settings 

If you’re drawn to non-traditional engagement rings in the UK, consider modern and artistic settings. These can include asymmetrical designs, mixed metals, and innovative use of space and light to create a truly unique piece. As a bespoke engagement ring specialist this is the perfect chance to add all of the special details that are important to you. Because each of my rings is made in collaboration with the client, we can add anything that you think will make the ring even more special.

Choosing the Perfect Stone 

Start by selecting a stone that catches your eye. Whether it’s a classic diamond or a vibrant coloured gemstone, your choice should reflect your personal style and the story of your relationship. For something truly unique why not consider something like a parti sapphire with their mesmerising colour combinations. For an in-depth look at choosing a diamond, take a look at this guide on the perfect diamond colour for you.

Selecting the Ideal Metal for the Band 

The metal of the band can influence the ring’s overall aesthetic. Options include traditional yellow gold or white gold, contemporary platinum, or romantic rose gold. A great choice for platinum lovers who want a coloured diamond is to have the band in platinum with the diamond set in yellow gold.

Adding Personal Engravings 

Personal engravings add a sentimental touch to your ring. Consider engraving a special date, initials, or a meaningful phrase that holds significance in your relationship. These can be done on the outside of the band or inside for only the wearer to see.

Incorporating Ethical and Sustainable Materials 

For those who prioritise sustainability, opt for ethically sourced stones and recycled metals. This ensures your beautiful ring also aligns with your values. From antique diamonds that have been recycled, fairtrade gold that gives back to the mining communities directly and Canadian diamonds there are lots of ethical options when it comes to creating an engagement ring that’s sustainable.

Some of my favourite Solitaires

Comparing Different Engagement Ring Design Styles

When it comes to design styles, there are endless possibilities:

Classic vs. Contemporary Designs

 Classic designs offer timeless elegance, while contemporary styles bring modern flair. Decide which aesthetic speaks to you and your partner’s tastes. There are subtle differences such as the shape of a claw or choosing a flat band over a rounded one that can have a huge difference to the overall aesthetic of your ring.

Minimalist vs. Intricate Detailing 

Minimalist rings focus on clean lines and simplicity, whereas intricate detailing like filigree in-between the claws or an engraved pattern on the band that can add complexity and uniqueness to the design. Consider what reflects your personal style best.

Traditional vs. Alternative Gemstones 

Traditional diamonds are always a stunning choice, but alternative gemstones can offer a unique and personalised touch. Whether you choose a solitaire diamond ring or a coloured gemstone engagement ring, both options have their charm. Do you have a colourful wardrobe or is it more monochrome? Taking thought to your or your partners choice of fashion can be a big help to deciding on a diamond or coloured gemstone.

Identifying Your Personal Style 

Reflect on your personal style and preferences. Do you prefer bold and quirky engagement rings or understated elegance? Knowing your style will guide your choices.

Setting a Budget for Your Custom Ring 

Determine a budget that feels comfortable for you. Remember, you can create a stunning ring at any price point by prioritising what’s most important to you. You’re creating a ring that is going to be worn for a lifetime so make sure not to compromise too much whilst being sure not to stretch too far. You don’t want to start your newly engaged life with stresses over paying for the ring.

Working with a Jeweller to Bring Your Vision to Life 


Partnering with a skilled jeweller ensures your vision is expertly brought to life. At Poppy Elder Fine Jewellery, I specialise in creating bespoke, non-traditional engagement rings in the UK, tailored to your unique love story.

Bespoke Engagement Ring Proposal

Creating a unique and meaningful engagement ring is a journey worth taking.

Whether you’re drawn to bezel set engagement rings, claw set engagement rings, or alternative single stone engagement rings, the possibilities are endless.

Explore our Unusual Engagement Ring collection and contact me for personalised assistance in designing your dream ring. Let’s craft a piece that truly reflects your love and commitment.

Feel free to reach out with any questions—we’re here to help you create the perfect bespoke engagement ring that you and your partner will cherish forever.

Book a consultation